Catering Now Available at All our Locations!

CLICK HERE to download PDF copy of CATERING MENU (Acrobat Reader Required)

Dear Loyal Customer,

For almost the last 85 years Heinemann’s has been delighting the Milwaukee area with homemade, all-natural and delicious treats. From hand dipped candies in our original 1923 candy shop, to hand baked breads, cookies, pies and cakes from our bakeries, to wonderful soups, casseroles and entrees in our restaurants, we have taken the finest, all- natural ingredients and created generations of sensational, healthy and loyal customers.

So on this, the eve of our 85th year; we wanted to bring to you our loyal customers something special – Heinemann’s Take It Away Catering! We offer here what many of you have told us are your very favorites and what many of you have asked us to prepare in ways you can share with your family, friends and business associates. We hope that you enjoy our new catering menu and continue to show us your incredible support. As always, we would love to hear your feedback along with anything we can do to make Heinemann’s catering an awesome experience for you.

Meggy Burns
Director of Operations and Catering
Assorted Bagel Platter
Cinnamon Raisin, Sesame Seed and Plain bagels served with Cream Cheese and Jam.
$33.00 (approximately $2.75 per person)
18” serves10-12 people
Fresh, Assorted Seasonal Fruit Platter
18”- $77.00, (approximately $3.50 per person), 12”- $42.00 (approximately $3.50 per person)
18” serves 20-22 people, 12” serves 10-12 people
Heinemann’s Homemade Specialty Bread Platter
$37.50 (approximately $2.50 per person)
Specialty choice from our monthly Bakery Schedule
18” serves 12-15 people
Heinemann’s Famous Baked Oatmeal
$37.50 (approximately $2.50 per person)
This item is sold cold with proper heating instructions.
½ Sheet Pan serves 12-15 people
Gourmet Brunch Bakes
Heinemann’s unique twist on a crustless egg quiche, filled with
Yukon Gold Hash Browns and a variety of tasty ingredients- $25.50 (approximately $4.25 per person)
Choose from a wide selection of favorites.
This item is sold cold with proper heating instructions.
9” serves 4-6 people per pan
Mini Muffin Variety Platter
Charlie the Bakers’ delicious assortment of Heinemann’s homemade mini-muffins.
$15.00 (approximately $1.25 per person)
18” serves10-12 people
Farm Fresh Scrambled Eggs
$42.00 (approximately $3.50 per person)
Pan serves 10-12 people
Sausage Lovers’
A combination of Heinemann’s own Turkey Sausage patties and Pork Sausage Links
$30.00 (approximately $2.50 per person)
Pan serves 10-12 people
Crispy Bacon
$30.00 (approximately $2.50 per person)
Our double smoked bacon serves 10-12 people
Fresh Fruit and Cheese Platter
Sliced Mozzarella, Cheddar, Swiss and Pepper Jack Cheese alongside an assortment of seasonal fresh fruit.
$65.00 (approximately $3.25 per person)
18” serves 18-20 people
Traditional Cheese Platter
Sliced Mozzarella, Cheddar, Swiss and Pepper Jack; garnished to perfection!
$55.00 18” serves 18-20 people (approximately $2.75 per person)
$27.50 12” serves 8-10 people (approximately $2.75 per person)
Fresh Shrimp Platter
Cleaned, cooked and peeled, 26-30 count large, chilled Shrimp with layers of colorful purple kale,
fresh lemon wedges, and our own cocktail sauce.
$50.00 (2 lbs)
12” serves 10-12 people
Garden Fresh Vegetable Platter
A colorful arrangement of fresh vegetables served with Heinemann’s homemade, Lo-calorie Ranch dressing.
$58.50 (approximately $3.25 per person)
18” serves 16-18 people
Spinach and Artichoke Dip
Served with Pita triangles and delicately displayed on a bed of fresh greens.
$30.00 (approximately $3.00 per person)
Serves 8-10 people
Heinemann’s Homemade Hummus and Pita
Served with Pita triangles, fresh, diced tomatoes and cucumbers on a bed of fresh greens.
$35.00 (approximately $3.50 per person)
Serves 8-10 people
Snack Tray for All Occasions
A perfect balance of healthy snacks and tasty treats! An assortment of Heinemann’s homemade Brownies,
Cookies, Carrot Sticks, and Pretzel Twists.
$36.00 (approximately $3.00 per person)
Add Heinemann’s homemade Lo-calorie Ranch dressing, as a dip for an additional $6.99.
18” serves 10-12 people
Fiesta Taco Dip (Chips are included)
A creamy dip combined with Mexican Seasonings and then topped with Chopped Lettuce,
Shredded Cheddar Cheese, Black Olives, Chopped Tomatoes and Chopped Scallions, set on a bed of fresh greens.
$48.75 (approximately $3.25 per person)
Add Mexican Chorizo for an additional $10 per platter
18” serves 13-15 people
Heinemann’s Fabulous Chicken Salad
$35.00 (approximately $3.50 per person)
Large bowl serves 8-10 people
Premium Meat Platter
An arrangement of our select deli meats, Roast Beef, Smoked Ham and our 100% natural Roast Turkey,
all nicely rolled and surrounded by fresh greens.
$84.00 (approximately $3.50 per person)
18” serve 20- 24 people
The Works
Can’t go wrong with this specialty! Includes 4-18” Platters; 1 Sliced Assorted Cheese, 1-Premium Meat, 1-Sandwich Topper
and 1-homemade pre-sliced roll Platter. Your choice of Welsh Rye and/or Herb Cheese dinner rolls.
$160.00 (approximately $8.00 per person)
Serves 18-20 people
Light Bite Sandwiches
Your choice of Heinemann’s homemade rolls: Welsh Rye or Herb Cheese, filled with Roast Beef, Smoked Ham
or our all Natural Roast Turkey, and then topped with Lettuce and Tomato.
$44.00 (approximately $2.75 per person)
-Mayonnaise and Mustard Packets are available upon request.
18” serves14-16 people
Gourmet Sandwich Platter
A variety of sandwiches to meet everyone’s taste! Our all Natural Roast Turkey with Swiss,
Smoked Ham with Cheddar and Roast Beef with Mozzarella, piled high with Lettuce, Tomatoes
and Grey Poupon mustard served on an assortment of our homemade gourmet flat breads.
$78.00 (approximately $6.50 per person)
18” serves 10-12 people
Gourmet Croissant Sandwich Platter
Your choice of Roast Beef, Smoked Ham, or our all Natural Roast Turkey, and topped with Lettuce and Tomatoes.
$66.00 (approximately $5.50 per person)
-Mayonnaise and Mustard Packets are available upon request.
-Add your favorite cheese for an additional 0.75¢ per person
18” serves 10-12 people
Bag O’ Chili El Grande Lunch (Seasonal)
Impress your guests with our out of this world, homemade Chili!
We provide you with a gallon bag of our Chili, toppings of Chopped Tomatoes, Scallions, Sour Cream
and Shredded Cheddar Cheese and you simply heat the chili! Ideal for football game parties!
$38.50 (approximately $2.75 per person)
Serves 12-14 people
Build Your Own Sandwich Box

Minimum of 10 required per order.
$8.25 per person
1st - Choose your homemade gourmet flat bread:
• Poppy Seed
• Wheat
• Sun-dried Tomato
2nd - Meat and Cheese Choice:
• Heinemann’s all Natural Roast Turkey with Swiss
• Smoked Ham with Cheddar
• Roast Beef with Mozzarella
3rd - Choose your Side:
• Cole Slaw
• Pasta Salad
• Homemade Potato Chips
• Carrot Sticks
4th - Homemade Dessert Choice:
• Creamy, Iced Brownie
• Homemade Cookie of the Day
5th. - Condiments:
• Mayo Packet
• Mustard Packet
All Boxed Salad Lunches come with:
• Your choice of Heinemann’s homemade dinner roll or Specialty bread of the day.
• Choice of homemade dressing: Lo-calorie Ranch, No Fat French, 1000 Island, Dijon, Cleopatra,
RaspberryVinaigrette, Italian Vinaigrette, or Balsamic Vinaigrette.
• Choice of homemade Iced Brownie or Cookie of the day.

Minimum of 10 required per order
$8.99 per person
Turkey Club Salad
Homemade Croutons, Bacon Strips, Mozzarella Cheese, Heinemann’s all Natural Roast Turkey,
Fresh Tomatoes and Cucumbers, on a bed of Fresh Greens.
Double Scoops
Your choice of 2 scoops of any one of our homemade Salads:
Fabulous Chicken Salad, Albacore Tuna Salad, or Creamy Egg Salad,
surrounded with homemade croutons, Fresh Tomatoes, Cucumbers, and Carrots all on a bed of Fresh Greens.
Garden Fresh Salad
Homemade Croutons, Fresh Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Onions, Carrots, Tomatoes, Cucumbers
and Shredded Cheddar Cheese, atop a bed of Fresh Greens.
Roast Turkey Dinner
Best in Town! Heinemann’s all Natural Roast Turkey topped with our homemade Turkey Gravy,
served with a steaming pan of Red Skinned Mashed Potatoes, Green Bean Almandine,
homemade Dinner Rolls and Heinemann’s own Cranberry/Orange Relish.
$122.50 (approximately $8.75 per person)
Serves 12-14 people
Grandma Dorothy’s Old Fashioned Meatloaf
Heinemann’s homemade hearty Meatloaf topped with Our own Mushroom Gravy,
accompanied with a pan of our creamy, Red Skinned Mashed Potatoes, Steamed Mixed Vegetables
and Heinemann’s homemade Dinner Rolls.
$95.00 (approximately $7.95 per person)
Serves 10-12 people
Homemade Chicken Stroganoff
A mouth watering white wine sauce filled with whole Button Mushrooms, large pieces of white Chicken Meat
and seasoned to perfection! Served with a pan of Egg Noodles and Heinemann’s homemade Dinner Rolls.
$79.50 (approximately $7.95 per person)
Serves 8-10 people
Heinemann’s Top Hat Chicken Pot Pie
Better than your average Chicken Pot Pie! Plentiful pieces of White Chicken, Potatoes, Peas, Carrots,
and just enough seasonings, topped with our delicate, flaky Crust, served with a dozen homemade Dinner Rolls.
$60.00 (approximately $5.00 per person)
Serves 10-12 people
We prepare and cook these entrees and allow you the luxury to bake according
to your schedule! While actual heating times may vary depending on your oven,
our simple heating instructions are provided with these dishes.

Please allow us a 48 hour notice for these selections.
Tuna Noodle Kugel
A classic made with Albacore White Tuna!
$17.99 (approximately $2.99 per person)
Add a half dozen homemade dinner rolls for $2.50
Serves 4-6 people
Gourmet Baked Macaroni and Cheese
A favorite for any age! Our homemade Macaroni and Cheese topped with a thick layer of aged Cheddar Cheese.
$45.00 (approximately $3.00 per person)
Add a dozen and a half homemade dinner rolls for $5.50
½ Sheet pan serves 12-15 people
Seafood Lasagna
Layers of Lobster and Surimi Crab, Heinemann’s homemade, creamy Alfredo Sauce, Spinach,
Our Special Spices and Lasagna Noodles, topped with Parmesan, Ricotta and Mozzarella Cheese.
Your guests will be impressed! Includes a side of Grated Parmesan Cheese
$60.00 (approximately $5.00 per person)
Add a loaf of Heinemann’s homemade Garlic French Bread for an additional $4.50
Serves 10-12 people
Vegetable Lasagna
A wonderful blend of Broccoli, Mushrooms, Onions, Ricotta, Parmesan, Pimento and Mozzarella Cheese,
layered between Lasagna Noodles and then topped with Heinemann’s homemade Garlic Tomato Sauce.
Seasoned to perfection! Includes a side of Grated Parmesan Cheese
$54.00 (approximately $4.50 per person)
Add a loaf of Heinemann’s homemade Garlic French Bread for an additional $4.50
Serves 10-12 people
Zesty Italian Lasagna
Three layers of Lasagna Noodles and Italian Sausage, Mushrooms, Onions, Garlic, and Seasonings,
combined with Ricotta, Mozzarella, Parmesan, and Asiago Cheese. Completed with a thick layer
of mouth-watering, Italian Tomato Sauce on top. Includes a side of Grated Parmesan Cheese
$57.00 (approximately $4.75 per person)
Add a loaf of Heinemann’s homemade Garlic French Bread for an additional $4.50
Serves 10-12 people
Cheesy, Spinach Pie
A Heinemann’s Classic!
Spinach, Onion, and Feta topped with a rich layer of Cheese, inside of our flaky, homemade crust.
$14.99 (approximately $2.49 per person)
Add a half dozen homemade dinner rolls for $2.50
Serves 4-6 people
Pasta Salad Bowl
Heinemann’s famous recipe! Tri-colored Rotini Pasta with Peas, Onions, Carrots,and Celery, mixed with our creamy dressing. Garnished to perfection with Fresh Lettuce and colorful Purple Kale.
$27.00 (approximately $2.25 per person)
Serves 10-12 people
Mixed Salad Pan
Fresh Greens mixed with Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Carrots, Onion Rings, homemade Croutons and
your choice of one of our homemade Dressings: Lo-calorie Ranch, 1000 Island, No Fat French, Dijon, Cleopatra,
RaspberryVinaigrette, Italian Vinaigrette, or Balsamic Vinaigrette.
$17.50 (approximately $1.75 per person)
Serves 8-10 people
Mashed Potato Pan
Creamy, Red-Skinned Mashed Potatoes.
$23.88 (approximately $1.99 per person)
Serves 10-12 people
Homemade Turkey Gravy
Delicious with our Creamy Mashed Potatoes!
$8.99 (approximately .75¢ per serving)
Serves 10-12 people
Homemade Cranberry/Orange Relish
Fresh, with just the right twist of sweet and tangy!
$9.99 (approximately .99¢ per serving)
Serves 8-12 people
Homemade Dinner Rolls
Baked fresh daily! Your choice of Welsh Rye Rolls or Herb Cheese Rolls.
Bag of a dozen: $3.99
Steamed, Mixed Vegetables
Cauliflower, Carrots and Broccoli with just a hint of Olive Oil andSeasonings.
$23.88 (approximately $1.99 per person)
Serves 10-12 people
Green Bean Almandine
Steamed Green Beans with our own Almond Butter.
$23.88 (Approximately $1.99 per person)
Serves 10-12 people
Sandwich Topper Tray
Fresh Tomatoes, Greens, Onions, and Dill Pickle Slices, Mustard and Mayonnaise Packets.
Perfect Platter for your guests to build their own Sandwich Buns!
$35.00 (approximately $1.75 per person)
Serves 18-20 people
Creamy Cole-Slaw
$19.90 (approximately $1.99 per person)
Serves 8-10 people
Homemade Potato Chips
Made Fresh Daily!
$7.50 (approximately $1.25 per person), Small bag serves 4-6 people
$15.00 (approximately $1.25 per person), Catering Bowl serves 10-12 people
Homemade Lush Torte
A classic at Heinemann’s, back to make your event even sweeter!
Unforgettable! Creamy Toffee/Mocha Icing, 4 layers of Sponge Cake and Crunchy Heath Toffee bits. You will not regret this!
$35.00 (approximately $2.99 per person)
Serves 10-12 people
Homemade Cookie Platter
Charlie the Bakers’ delicious selection! Garnished with colorful mini M&M’s.
$15.00 (approximately $1.00 per person)
Serves 18-20 people
Homemade Iced Brownie Tray
Rich and luscious!
$30.00; approximately $1.50 per person
Serves 18-20 people
Charlie’s Homemade Pies
Choose from one of our current selections!
$14.00 (approximately $2.00 per person)
Serves up to 7 people
Old Fashioned Fruit Cobbler
$55.00 (approximately $3.99 per person)
½ sheet pan serves 15-25 people
Homemade ½ Sheet Cakes
Please allow us 72 hours
$48.00 (approximately $2.99 per person)
Serves 40-48 people
Homemade Cookie and Brownie Tray
$30.00 (approximately $1.50 per person)
Serves 18-20 people
12 oz. Styrofoam Cups and Lids are included with each beverage below.
96 oz. Coffee to Go
Heinemann’s delicious own blend! Coffee box keeps coffee hot for up to 3 hours.
$25.88 (approximately $2.15 per person)
Creamers and Sweeteners available upon request
Serves 10-12 people
96 oz. Decaffeinated Coffee to Go
Heinemann’s delicious own blend! Coffee box keeps coffee hot for up to 3 hours.
$25.88 (approximately $2.15 per person)
Creamers and Sweeteners are available upon request
Serves 10-12 people
2 Liter Sprite, Coke, or Diet Coke
$2.75
25 oz. Spring Water Bottles
$1.25
Gallon of Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice
Florida’s best; All natural, fresh squeezed juice.
$13.50
• Plastic Serving utensils are included with entrees as needed
• Plastic ware is available upon request only
• Please allow Heinemann’s a 24 hour notice for Catering orders, unless specified differently next to item.
  This allows us the proper amount of time needed in order to present you with our finest quality meals.
  However, we will do our best to accommodate last minute orders, considering product availability.
• Prices listed do not include tax
• Prices listed are subject to change at any time without advanced notice
• Heinemann’s is open to any ideas or suggestions on our catering menu, so your feedback is more than welcome.
• Our hot items are placed in foil pans and oven ready. We do suggest that the food be reheated at your
  location to ensure the highest quality food.
• Heinemann’s accepts Visa, Mastercard and Discover. No checks please.
• Heinemann’s requires a credit card number for all orders exceeding $100.00
• Changes and/or cancellations involve concern on both party’s ends.
  Should you need to make a change in your order, please call as far in advance as possible.
  If you need to cancel an order, we require you to do so 24 hours prior to your pick-up date.
  You will be responsible for any cancellations that occur after the 24 hour deadline.